Chapter 2: Social responsibility

Definition

Capitalism: An economic system characterized by private ownership of the means of production, where individuals and businesses operate for profit within a competitive marketplace.

  • Self-Interest Driven: Individuals and businesses act primarily out of self-interest, but the free market system can still lead to beneficial outcomes for society.
  • Private Ownership: Individuals and companies own resources and businesses.
  • Profit Motive: The primary goal is to generate profit, driving innovation and efficiency.
  • Market Competition: Businesses compete to attract consumers, influencing prices and quality.
  • Supply and Demand: Prices fluctuate based on consumer demand and the availability of goods and services.
  • Economic Growth: Can lead to increased productivity and improved living standards.
  • Critiques: Concerns include income inequality, environmental degradation, and potential monopolistic practices.

Capitalism, with its emphasis on market competition and profit maximization, has often been criticized for prioritizing short-term gains over long-term societal well-being. However, the integration of social sustainability into capitalist frameworks presents a transformative opportunity. By prioritizing ethical practices, fair labor conditions, and environmental stewardship, businesses can align their profit motives with the needs of communities and ecosystems. This approach fosters innovation and resilience, encouraging companies to adopt sustainable practices that not only enhance their brand reputation but also contribute to the overall health of society. Ultimately, capitalism can evolve to support a more equitable and sustainable future, where economic growth and social responsibility coexist harmoniously.

Under capitalism, stakeholder consideration has become increasingly vital as businesses recognize that their success is intertwined with the interests of various groups affected by their operations. Stakeholders include not only shareholders but also employees, customers, suppliers, communities, and the environment. This broader perspective encourages companies to go beyond profit maximization and consider the social and environmental impacts of their actions. Engaging with stakeholders can lead to improved decision-making, enhanced reputation, and greater trust, ultimately fostering long-term sustainability. By balancing the needs and expectations of diverse stakeholders, businesses can create value not just for themselves but for society as a whole, contributing to a more equitable and responsible capitalist system.

Corporate Social Responsibility

In relation to equity, CSR plays a pivotal role in fostering social inclusivity and addressing social inequalities. Companies that prioritize CSR actively engage in efforts to promote diversity, equity, and inclusion within their workforce and supply chains. They strive to create equal opportunities for employees from diverse backgrounds and ensure fair treatment for all.

Moreover, CSR initiatives often target marginalized communities to uplift and empower them, promoting social equity through various social programs and partnerships. By considering the needs of vulnerable groups and supporting projects that enhance social well-being, companies contribute to a more equitable society.

Definition

Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR): A business model in which companies integrate social and environmental concerns into their operations and interactions with stakeholders. CSR goes beyond profit generation, emphasizing ethical practices, sustainable resource management, and community engagement. It involves a commitment to conduct business in ways that are socially responsible, including fair labor practices, environmental stewardship, and philanthropy, ultimately aiming to create positive impacts on society while achieving financial success.

Carroll’s Pyramid of Corporate Social Responsibility (CSR) is a framework that outlines the different levels of responsibility that businesses have toward society. Developed by Archie B. Carroll in 1991, the pyramid consists of four tiers, each representing a different aspect of corporate responsibility:

  1. Economic Responsibility: At the base of the pyramid, businesses are expected to be profitable and economically viable. This foundation supports the other responsibilities, as financial success allows companies to contribute positively to society.
  2. Legal Responsibility: Above economic responsibilities, companies must adhere to laws and regulations. Compliance with legal standards ensures that businesses operate fairly and ethically within the framework of the law.
  3. Ethical Responsibility: This tier emphasizes the importance of ethical behaviour beyond mere compliance. Businesses are expected to act in ways that are morally sound, considering the broader impact of their decisions on stakeholders, including employees, customers, and the community.
  4. Philanthropic Responsibility: At the top of the pyramid, philanthropic responsibilities involve voluntary actions that contribute to the welfare of society, such as charitable donations, community engagement, and support for social causes. While not mandatory, these efforts enhance a company’s reputation and foster goodwill.

Together, these tiers illustrate that corporate social responsibility encompasses not only financial performance but also legal, ethical, and philanthropic dimensions, encouraging businesses to contribute positively to society while pursuing their economic goals.

The Pentagon Model of Social Sustainability

Measuring social sustainability is difficult. However, over time, academic scholars have started to develop some consensus on what a sustainable society should look like. These criteria can be summarized by the Pentagon Model of Social Sustainability proposed by Akcali and Cahantimur (2022). The model includes five interconnected dimensions of social sustainability, as shown below.

Place

The “Place” dimension considers the physical infrastructures that support the thriving of society. It encompasses various aspects of the physical environment that directly impact the quality of life for individuals and communities. Key aspects considered under this dimension include the following.

  1. Community Spaces: These include public parks, recreational areas, community centers, and other shared spaces where people can gather, interact, and engage in social activities. Well-designed community spaces contribute to a sense of belonging and cohesion within neighborhoods.
  2. Healthcare Facilities: Accessible and well-equipped healthcare facilities, including hospitals, clinics, and other medical services, are crucial for maintaining the health and well-being of a population. Availability and proximity to healthcare services are essential components of a thriving community.
  3. Education Facilities: Schools, colleges, and other educational institutions form a vital part of the “Place” dimension. Access to quality education is fundamental for individual growth, community development, and the overall progress of society.
  4. Affordable Housing: Adequate and affordable housing is a cornerstone of a healthy community. Housing stability contributes to social and economic well-being, and ensuring a range of housing options can help address the diverse needs of the population.
  5. Transportation Infrastructure: Efficient and accessible transportation systems, including roads, public transit, and pedestrian-friendly pathways, play a significant role in connecting communities and enabling people to access various services and opportunities.
  6. Environmental Considerations: This involves the quality of the natural environment within a community, including clean air, water, and green spaces. Sustainable and environmentally friendly practices contribute to the overall health and resilience of the community.

People

The “People” dimension considers social cohesion, social identity, and the interactions among individuals within a community. Key aspects within the “People” dimension include the following:

  1. Social Adhesion: This refers to the strength of social bonds and connections within a community. Strong social adhesion is characterized by positive relationships, cooperation, and a sense of unity among individuals. It fosters a supportive community environment where people feel connected to one another.
  2. Social Identity: Social identity encompasses the shared values, norms, and cultural elements that define a community. It involves a sense of belonging to a group with common characteristics, such as cultural background, traditions, or shared experiences. Social identity contributes to a sense of community and shared purpose.
  3. Inclusivity and Diversity: A thriving community embraces diversity and promotes inclusivity. This involves creating an environment where individuals from various backgrounds, cultures, and perspectives feel valued and included. Celebrating diversity enhances the richness of social interactions and promotes understanding among community members.
  4. Shared Values and Ethics: Establishing and reinforcing shared values and ethical principles within a community helps guide individual behavior and fosters a sense of shared responsibility. This contributes to the creation of a moral and ethical foundation for the community.
  5. Communication and Dialogue: Open and effective communication is essential for building and maintaining social cohesion. This includes both interpersonal communication and broader community dialogues that facilitate understanding, resolve conflicts, and encourage collaboration.
  6. Social Support Systems: Building networks of social support is crucial for the well-being of individuals. This can include informal support from friends and family, as well as more formal structures such as community organizations, support groups, and social services that provide assistance during times of need.

Population

The “Population” or “Person” dimension considers the demographic and household characteristics that are crucial to the survival and thriving of the society. This dimension focuses on understanding and addressing the characteristics, diversity, and dynamics of the individuals who make up the community. Important aspects under the “Population” dimension include the following key characteristics.

  1. Demographic Composition: This involves analyzing and understanding the population’s characteristics, such as age distribution, gender, ethnicity, education levels, and socioeconomic status. Demographic information provides insights into the diverse needs and challenges faced by different segments of the population.
  2. Population Growth and Trends: Monitoring population growth rates and demographic trends is essential for planning and resource allocation. Understanding how the population is changing over time helps communities adapt to evolving needs and challenges.
  3. Household Structures: Examining the composition of households, including family size, living arrangements, and generational structures, provides insights into the social dynamics and support systems within the community. It also influences housing and infrastructure planning.
  4. Health and Well-being: The health and well-being of individuals are critical factors in the “Population” dimension. This includes access to healthcare, mental health support, nutrition, and overall quality of life. Addressing health disparities and promoting a healthy lifestyle contribute to the well-being of the community.
  5. Education and Skills: The educational background and skills of the population are key components in determining the community’s capacity for personal and collective development. Ensuring access to quality education and skill development opportunities enhances the overall capabilities of the population.

Process

The “Process” dimension reflects the resilience and flexibility of a society to change. This dimension focuses on the processes, systems, and mechanisms in place that enable a community to effectively navigate and respond to various challenges, uncertainties, and transformations.

  1. Adaptive Governance: The ability of a society to adapt and respond to change is closely tied to its governance structures. Adaptive governance involves flexible decision-making processes, inclusive policies, and the capacity to adjust strategies in response to evolving circumstances.
  2. Innovation and Technology: Embracing innovation and leveraging technology can enhance a society’s adaptability. This includes the adoption of new technologies, digital infrastructure, and innovative solutions to address emerging challenges and improve efficiency in various sectors.
  3. Economic Resilience: Building economic resilience involves diversifying economic activities, promoting entrepreneurship, and creating policies that buffer against economic shocks. Flexible economic systems can better withstand changes in global markets and economic conditions.
  4. Flexibility to support future lifestyles: This involves creating systems, environments, and structures that can adapt to and accommodate the changing needs, preferences, and challenges of individuals and communities.
  5. Community Engagement and Participation: Inclusive decision-making processes and active community participation are essential for building resilience. Engaging the community in discussions, planning, and implementation of policies fosters a sense of ownership and collective responsibility.

Perception

The “Perception” dimension considers society members’ sense of place and their feelings of safety and security. It focuses on how members of society perceive their surroundings, including their sense of place, safety, and security. This dimension recognizes the subjective experiences, emotions, and attitudes that individuals have toward their environment. Key aspects can include:

  1. Safety and Security Perception: Visible and effective public safety measures, such as law enforcement presence, well-lit areas, and surveillance systems, contribute to a sense of security.
  2. Sense of Justice and Legal Protection: refers to the perception that individuals have regarding the fairness, equity, and effectiveness of the legal system in safeguarding their rights, ensuring justice, and providing protection against injustices.
  3. Community and economic stability: The stability of a community is often reflected in the social, economic, and environmental conditions that contribute to a sense of security, prosperity, and overall quality of life.
  4. Perceived Opportunities: The perception of available economic opportunities and job prospects influences residents’ overall satisfaction and sense of security.

Goodness is the only investment that never fails.

~~ Henry David Thoreau

Knowledge Check!

Resources

  • Balmer, J. M., Fukukawa, K., & Gray, E. R. (2007). The nature and management of ethical corporate identity: A commentary on corporate identity, corporate social responsibility and ethics. Journal of Business Ethics, 76(1), 7-15. https://doi.org/10.1007/s10551-006-9278-z
  • Sustainability Illustrated. (2021, May 28). CSR: What is corporate social responsibility? Definition examples benefits [Video]. YouTube. https://youtu.be/Zc102xiah1M?si=7Ig8USJbDjEDny_y
  • Carroll, A. B. (1991). The Pyramid of Corporate Social Responsibility: Toward the Moral Management of Organizational Stakeholders. Business Horizons, 34(4), 39-48.

 

License

Icon for the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License

Exploring Sustainability Copyright © 2024 by Sobey School of Business, Saint Mary's University is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License, except where otherwise noted.

Share This Book